The 3rd Joint Regional Financing Arrangement (RFA) Research Seminar
Date & Time: Thursday and Friday, May 16-17, 2019
Location: 8 Rue du Château, 6162 Bourglinster, Luxembourg
The 3rd Joint Regional Financing Arrangement (RFA) Research Seminar co-organized by the ASEAN+3 Macroeconomic Research Office (AMRO), the European Stability Mechanism (ESM), and the Fondo Latinoamericano de Reservas (FLAR), will be held on May 16 and 17, 2019 in Luxembourg. The seminar is an annual event aiming at bringing academics and institutions together to discuss key issues pertaining to global and regional financial stability.
Given heightened global risks related to trade tensions, geopolitical challenges, and economic and market uncertainties, this year our research seminar will focus on detecting, analysing, preventing, and tackling sovereign risks and how the Global Financial Safety Net, in particular its regional line of defence, can provide enhanced support.
Mr Klaus Regling, Managing Director of European Stability Mechanism (ESM), and Mr José Darío Uribe, Executive President of Fondo Latinoamericano de Reservas (FLAR), will make the introductory remarks. Mr Yasuto Watanabe, AMRO Deputy Director, will make the closing remarks. The event comprises two academic sessions and a roundtable. AMRO Chief Economist Dr Hoe Ee Khor will chair the first academic session themed “Diagnose current global sovereign risks”, while Dr Li Lian Ong, AMRO Lead Specialist and Group Head (Surveillance) will speak about the Economic Review and Policy Dialogue (ERPD) Scorecard and ARTEMIS as effective risk detection tools.
The audience will be a mix of academics, economists from central banks and finance ministries, representatives from RFAs, the IMF, and other institutions.
The event is by invitation only.
MAY 16, 2019 (THURSDAY)
|8:30 – 9:00||Registration and welcome coffee|
|9:00 – 9:15||Introductory Remarks
Klaus Regling, Managing Director – European Stability Mechanism
José Darío Uribe, Executive President – Latin American Reserve Fund
|9:15 – 12:30||Academic Session 1: Diagnose current global sovereign risks
Chair: Hoe Ee Khor, Chief Economist – ASEAN+3 Macroeconomic Research Office
|9:15 – 9:45||Galina Hale, Research Advisor – Federal Reserve Bank of San Francisco
The euro crisis in the mirror of the European Monetary System
|9:45 – 10:15||Ilhyock Shim, Head of Economics and Financial Markets for Asia and the Pacific – Bank for International Settlements
Financial stress in lender countries and capital outflows from emerging market economies
|10:15 – 10:45||Coffee break|
|10:45 – 11:15||Moritz Kraemer, Chief Economic Advisor – Acreditus
Why sovereigns default?
|11:15 – 11:45||Discussant: Gong Cheng, Senior Economist – European Stability Mechanism|
|11:45 – 12:30||Q&A|
|12:30 – 14:00||Photo Session and Lunch|
|14:00 – 17:15||Academic Session 2: How to shape effective risk detection tools?
Chair: Nicola Giammarioli, Head of Strategy and Institutional Relations – European Stability Mechanism
|14:00 – 14:30||Phakawa Jeasakul and Romain Lafarguette, Economists – International Monetary Fund
Growth at Risk: Concept and Application in IMF Country Surveillance
|14:30 – 15:00||Jan Hannes Lang, Financial Stability Expert – European Central Bank
Anticipating the bust: a new cyclical systemic risk indicator to assess the likelihood and severity of financial crises
|15:00 – 15:15||Coffee break|
|15:15 – 15:45||Li Lian Ong, Group Head Financial Surveillance – ASEAN+3 Macroeconomic Research Office
The ERPD Matrix Scorecard and ARTEMIS
|15:45 – 16:15||Discussant: Dennis Essers, Economist – National Bank of Belgium|
|16:15 – 17:00||Q&A|
|17:00 – 17:15||Closing Keynote
Randall Henning, Professor at the School of International Service – American University
MAY 17, 2019 (FRIDAY)
|9:00 – 9:30||Arrival and welcome coffee|
|9:30 – 10:00||Keynote speech
Erik Berglöf, Director of the Institute of Global Affairs – London School of Economics
|10:00 – 12:15||Roundtable: Are the Global Financial Safety Net and crisis management institutions prepared
to early detect risks and fight against the next crisis? Chair: Rolf Strauch, Chief Economist – European Stability Mechanism PetyaDiscussants: Koeva Brooks, Deputy Director, Strategy, Policy, and Review Department – International Monetary FundCarlos Giraldo, Chief Economist – Latin American Reserve Fund Barbara Fritz, Professor at the Institute for
Latin American Studies / School of Business & Economics – Freie Universität BerlinMasahiro Kawai, Professor – University of TokyoBenoît Mojon, Head of Economic Analysis – Bank for International SettlementsHeinz Scherrer, Head of Unit, Directorate-General for Economic and Financial Affairs – European CommissionEvgeny Y. Vinokurov, Chief Economist – Eurasian Fund for Stabilisation and Development
|12:15 – 12:20||Closing Remarks
Yasuto Watanabe, Deputy Director – ASEAN+3 Macroeconomic Research Office
Closing Remarks by Mr Yasuto Watanabe, Deputy Director of AMRO
at the 3rd Joint Regional Financing Arrangement (RFA) Research Seminar
16-17 May 2019
(As prepared for delivery)
It is my honor to have the opportunity to reflect on what we have discussed in the past two days. We have covered a wide range of pertinent issues, including risk detection, focusing on some critical factors from the past European crises, risk transmitting mechanisms to emerging markets and sovereign default issues, as well as risk detection tools developed by the International Monetary Fund (IMF), the European Central Bank (ECB) and the ASEAN+3 Macroeconomic Office (AMRO). We also had a lively discussion on what Regional Financing Arrangements (RFAs) can do to prevent the next crisis.
My closing remarks will touch on where we stand in terms of development of the RFAs and how we can move forward in addressing possible future financial crises and securing financial stability regionally and globally.
Global economy: protectionism and capital flow volatility
The global economy is undergoing profound changes and facing increasing uncertainties that need to be carefully managed.
- First, rising protectionism and unilateralism. AMRO’s assessment suggests that in an adverse scenario of an escalating US-China trade tension when the two sides would impose tariffs of 25 percent on all imports between the two countries, the regional growth of ASEAN+3 growth will be hit by 0.4 percentage point over 2019 to 2020.
- Second, capital flow volatility and the risks of a sudden stop pose ever-present threats. Increased global interconnectedness suggests that external shocks tend to be amplified and transmitted quickly, with risks of broader spillovers. This is of particular concern to East Asian emerging markets as they have been receiving large amount of inflows of non-FDI capital accounting for 8 percent of GDP since the Global Financial Crisis (GFC).
- Third, technological advancements are changing the traditional risk transmission channels. Risks from cyber-crime and cyber-attacks, for example, may weaken the integrity of the financial system, undermine confidence, and potentially hamper policy transmission to the real economy.
- Lastly, climate change related risks which may pose more damage on the economies and the international financial system than ever.
Increasing role of RFAs
Given the threats and prolonged uncertainties in the global economy, enhancing the financial safety net, especially strengthening the role of RFAs, should be a priority. The size of the RFAs has increased significantly since the GFC and they are currently the second largest resource in the global financial safety net (GFSN), only after countries’ foreign reserves.
According to AMRO’s calculation, the overall volume of RFAs currently amounts to USD 1,553 billion, which is even larger than resources of the International Monetary Fund (IMF) at USD 1,357 billion. More significantly, the delayed discussion of the IMF quota increase would signify the policy shift to inward-looking direction by major economies.
The current trade war between the U.S. and China signals that the U.S. has withdrawn itself from the position as the guardian of the international trade system. It is likely that we will witness similar shifts in the U.S. policy on international finance, especially in terms of IMF funding and financing. If the leading countries are no longer willing to shoulder responsibility and assume leadership in tackling financial crises, other countries would have to rely more on self-help measures, including RFAs.
RFAs’ effectiveness and the level of coordination with other layers of the GFSN are still revealing room for improvement, and in some cases, untested.
The G20 Eminent Persons Group report released in 2018 conveys a similar message. The shortcomings of current RFAs identified by the report are two-fold:
- The system as a whole lacks the necessary coordination, and
- Several new RFAs, including the Chiang Mai Initiative Multilateralism (CMIM), have not been tested in an actual crisis.
Policymakers in the ASEAN+3 region are fully aware of these challenges. Given the legacy of the so-called “IMF stigma” in the region, CMIM parties need to strike a balance between improving CMIM as an independent facility and at the same time, enhancing coordination with the IMF. During the past years, the members, with support from AMRO have worked intensively on these tasks. Let me briefly share our experience.
- The members have recently concluded the first CMIM periodic review and one of its main objectives is to improve CMIM’s coordination with the IMF. For example, financing terms and conditions of CMIM-IMF linked portion were amended to ensure consistency with IMF programs. To enhance coordination with the IMF in terms of program and conditionality design, information-sharing procedure and conditionality framework were introduced. The review and monitoring procedure were also adjusted to be consistent with the IMF’s post-program process.
- On top of this, discussions to enhance CMIM’s effectiveness as an independent facility is also in progress. The ASEAN+3 members are discussing several options for the future directions of CMIM. In terms of institutional framework, the members are discussing the merit of introducing paid-in capital instead of current funding structure based on swap transaction. They are also examining the feasibility of broadening the mandate of CMIM to cover new types of threats such as natural disasters and structural issues. In addition, the members have conducted a study on local currency usage in CMIM funding and support.
Enhancing communication and knowledge exchange among RFAs
Our peer RFAs are also making similar efforts. For example, the ESM is undergoing reforms that encompass extended surveillance, crisis management, and a broader scope of financing in times of need. FLAR is also enhancing its structure and capacity. The European Fund for Stabilization and Development (EFSD) is moving towards enhancing its institutional arrangement.
In the exercise of upgrading RFAs, I strongly believe that we can learn from each other’s experience. For instance, when designing CMIM’s coordination process with the IMF, we took the experience of IMF co-financing by the Eurozone’s RFAs as benchmarks. We also hope that the ongoing efforts to enhance CMIM can be an inspiration for other RFAs to look into when upgrading theirs.
In this regard, this joint RFAs seminar is a very useful platform for us to exchange experiences and learn from each other. It would also be beneficial to promote effective communication and knowledge sharing. In this regard, the idea of establishing a virtual-knowledge hub, in addition to the current joint secretariat function, which all RFAs can access and share their knowledge might be worth exploring.
To conclude, I would like to thank ESM colleagues for your warm hospitality and excellent arrangement of the event, especially for hosting the event in this beautiful castle, which was built in the 11th century and has since then survived several wars. We would like to follow the history of this castle to defend our own region from external risks and the next crisis. Thank you all for your active participation. We look forward to seeing all of you at the 4th RFA Research Seminar next year.
3rd Joint Regional Financing Arrangements Research Seminar Discusses Sovereign Risk
Luxembourg, May 16, 2019 – The regional rescue funds will discuss, at their 3rd Joint Research Seminar in Luxembourg, how to detect, analyse, prevent and tackle sovereign risk and how they can provide enhanced support, given the heightened global risks related to trade tensions, geopolitical challenges and economic and market uncertainties.
The Regional Financing Arrangements (RFAs) Research Seminar is an annual event that brings together scholars and institutions to discuss technical issues relevant for RFAs’ operations. The ASEAN+3 Macroeconomic Research Office (AMRO), the European Stability Mechanism (ESM), and the Latin American Reserve Fund (FLAR) initiated this series of research seminars in 2017. Previous research seminars took place in Singapore and in Cartagena de Indias, Colombia.
“Academic research into the reasons behind financial crises and the efficacy of our policy tools plays an essential role in preparing us for potential crises going forward. This year, for the first time, technical experts from all seven major RFAs were able to be present, a clear recognition of the relevance and success of the two previous seminars,” said Klaus Regling, Managing Director at the ESM.
For the 3rd Joint RFA Research Seminar, organizers reached out to academics and researchers to have the latest studies available to enrich the discussion. The participants’ discussions will focus on current sovereign risks, highlighting banking sector issues, long-term fiscal costs, financial stress in lender countries and capital outflows from emerging market countries.
“Currently, the world is more indebted than a decade ago, both in the private as well as in the public realms. Although emerging and developing economies show a lower indebtedness than developed economies, their debt has been growing over the past 10 years and its cost is higher than it is for advanced economies. This demands a close surveillance of the economies,” pointed out José Darío Uribe, Executive President of FLAR.
The International Monetary Fund, the European Central Bank and AMRO will present their models and indicators to help detect sovereign risks, contributing to the discussion on how institutions could get better prepared with various early warning systems. Finally, participants will debate how to prepare the Global Financial Safety Net to detect risks early and fight the next crisis, and how to adjust policy to improve the effectiveness of defence mechanisms.
“Strong coordination is required among all players of the international financial system to prepare for the next crisis that could hit us. This research seminar is an important avenue to discuss issues that are crucial to strengthen each RFA’s capacity as well as the coordination among different layers of the Global Financial Safety Net,” said Yasuto Watanabe, Deputy Director of AMRO.
In addition to AMRO, as the macroeconomic surveillance arm of the Chiang Mai Initiative Multilateralisation, FLAR and the ESM, the other RFAs present at the seminar are the Arab Monetary Fund (AMF), the BRICS Contingent Reserve Arrangement (BRICS CRA) represented by the Central Bank of Brazil, the Eurasian Fund for Stabilization and Development (EFSD), the European Commission, through the EU Balance of Payments Facility. The IMF and the Bank for International Settlement, which both support global financial stability, also participated.
In addition to this technical-level gathering, the heads of RFAs and representatives of the IMF meet once a year at the High-level RFA policy dialogue to discuss the collaboration between the IMF and RFAs and among RFAs themselves. The 4th RFA High-Level Dialogue will convene on 16 October 2019 in Washington, D.C., on the sidelines of the IMF/World Bank Annual Meetings.